Indian Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology Research

Print ISSN: 2394-2746

Online ISSN: 2394-2754

CODEN : IJOGCS

Indian Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology Research (IJOGR) open access, peer-reviewed quarterly journal publishing since 2014 and is published under auspices of the Innovative Education and Scientific Research Foundation (IESRF), aim to uplift researchers, scholars, academicians, and professionals in all academic and scientific disciplines. IESRF is dedicated to the transfer of technology and research by publishing scientific more...


  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article statistics

Viewed: 244

PDF Downloaded: 159


Madhumithaa N and Kirubamani: A survey of women’s birth experiences using the Birth Satisfaction Scale–Revised Indicator (BSS-RI)


Introduction

The perinatal well-being of women belonging to the childbearing age group is of paramount importance to all institutions that provide maternity services throughout the country.1 The birth satisfaction during this period is of key importance in assessing the care provided and making suitable improvements. The experiences a woman undergoes during childbirth can influence her future childbearing options. The Birth Satisfaction Scale-Revised Indicator (BSS-RI) is a questionnaire that targets to supervise the experience of a childbearing woman during delivery.2 The BSS-RI is a six-item scale which is used to assess the birth satisfaction of the patients. The women assessed are considered as consumers of maternity care and their experiences are noted to make further improvements in service provision.3 Over the years, women’s maternity experiences have changed with advancing medical care and hence it is of vital importance to record their views and opinions. Since women consult clinicians most frequently because of childbirth, evaluation of the women’s level of satisfaction from intra-, and postpartum health care services provided by the health care setups is very important in increasing the quality of health care. Therefore, the experiences of women during the intrapartum period has gained increasing importance.4, 5, 6

Experiences related to childbirth directly interfere with the health and well-being of the mother and her new-born, as well as with the choice of a future delivery. Dissatisfaction with normal labour calls for an increase in the preference for Caesarean birth in future pregnancies and may cause impact on reproduction.7 The concept of satisfaction is complex and hence the patient’s satisfaction relies on the degree of quality provided by a health service. Hence, satisfaction with birth expresses the user’s assessment of the care received. Also, it is necessary to know more about the satisfaction levels experienced with different modes of delivery (normal delivery and Caesarean section) as this will help in improving the hospital environment according to the women’s needs and will also help in improving the women’s choice of future delivery. The BSS-RI will provide us with information about improvements in the hospital setup that can be made in order to facilitate a better childbearing experience for the mothers in the future. The varying satisfaction scores with respect to the women’s parity will also aid the doctors in introducing psychological counselling for primiparous women about what they need to know and expect, in order to reduce their stress regarding the outcomes of the pregnancy.

Material and Methods

A prospective cross-sectional study was conducted at the Obstetrics and Gynecology department of Saveetha Medical College and Hospital. After obtaining ethical clearance and informed consent, one hundred women who delivered over a period of three months were included in the study.

Description of tool

The six item Birth Satisfaction Scale-Revised Indicator (Table 1) was used to assess women after delivery. The survey was done by interview method within 10 days after the women delivered in the post-natal ward. The instrument was modified to a simplified 3-point scoring system with higher scores representing greater birth satisfaction (range 0–2). The items in the BSS-RI are further split into ‘a-items’ and ‘b-items’ with a separate scoring system for each (‘a’ items- “agree”=2, “agree to some degree”=1, “disagree”=0; ‘b’ items- “agree”=0, “agree to some degree”=1, “disagree”=2). The BSS-RI is further divided into three domains i.e., quality of care provision, women’s self-assessed attributes and stress experienced during labour. The scores of women undergoing different types of delivery (normal vaginal or Caesarean delivery) along with their parities (primipara or multipara) were compared and studied.

Table 1

Birth Satisfaction Scale–Revised Indicator (BSS-RI)

BSS-RI item

BSS-RI item content

Domain

BSS-RI 1

I was not distressed at all during labour (a)

Stress

BSS-RI 2

I felt very anxious during labour and birth (b)

Attributes

BSS-RI 3

I felt well supported by staff during my labour and birth (a)

Quality

BSS-RI 4

I found giving birth to be a distressing experience (a)

Stress

BSS-RI 5

I felt out of control during my birth experience (b)

Attributes

BSS-RI 6

The staff communicated well with me during labour (b)

Quality

Inclusion criteria

All willing mothers undergoing delivery at Saveetha Medical College and Hospital.

Exclusion criteria

  1. Women experiencing a perinatal loss.

  2. Young mothers less than 18 years of age.

  3. Other methods of delivery using forceps or vacuum.

Statistical analysis

For this study, data from 100 women was taken and their BSS-RI scores were analysed. The graphs used in this study were done with MS Excel and the frequency tables were also constructed. The exploratory statistics are given for each item set along with the standard deviation scores.

Results

A total of 100 women completed the 6-item BSS-RI (Table 1). Out of the 100 women, 57% underwent normal vaginal delivery while 43% underwent Caesarean section. Thirty-one participants were primiparas, while the rest were multiparas. The average age of the patients was 25.6 years. The general scores of birth satisfaction were positive, supporting that the women were overall satisfied with the birth experience provided by the institution.

Results based on the mode of delivery

The average satisfaction score in women undergoing normal vaginal delivery was 5.15, whereas the average satisfaction score in women undergoing Caesarean section was 4.62; indicating that Caesarean section had a lower amount of satisfaction (Figure 1). Satisfaction was also higher in women who delivered in the labour ward than those who delivered in operation theatre.

Results based on parity

The satisfaction scores were also higher in multiparous women with an average score of 5.24 than primiparous women, who had an average score of 4.22(Figure 2).

Age group variations

It can be observed from that most of the women participating in the study belong to an age group of 21-24 with a count of nearly 31. The least number of women are between the age of 33-36, with less than 5 people. This graph also clearly tells that all the women under the study are within the normal range of childbearing capabilities.

Mean and standard deviation

Table 2 indicates the mean BSS-RI scores with the standard deviation of the scores in parentheses. It can be seen that normal delivery had fetched a higher satisfaction than Caesarean section (C-Section). It can also be seen that BSS-RI with“a-items” scoring has a higher mean value, thereby a better score than the “b-items”.

Table 2

Mean BSS-RI scores for different attributes with standard deviation included in parentheses

Variable

Normal delivery (n=57)

Caeserean section (n=43)

Primiparas (n=31)

Multiparas (n=69)

BSS-RI (Total)

5.15(1.12)

4.62(1.00)

4.22(1.12)

5.24(1.12)

BSS-RI (a)

3.03(0.70)

3.65(0.52)

3.38(0.76)

3.26(0.67)

BSS-RI (b)

2.12(1.08)

0.97(0.80)

0.83(0.82)

1.98(1.06)

Frequency table

In Table 3, the characteristics are grouped into three divisions (birthing environment, type of childbirth and educational status) and the frequency based on the parity is mentioned.

Table 3

Birth characteristics frequency table based on parity

Primiparas (n=31)

Multiparas (n=69)

1) Birthing Environment:

i) Operation Theatre

16

27

ii) Labour Ward

15

42

2) Type of Child Birth:

i) Normal Delivery

15

42

ii) Caesarean Delivery

16

27

3) Educational Status:

i) Middle School

3

7

ii) High School

16

32

iii) Undergraduate

8

29

iv) Postgraduate

4

1

Figure 1

Comparison of scores between normal and Caesarean delivery

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/c4bc4a8c-12c2-4a6f-888d-5fc42ae45428image1.png

Figure 2

Comparison of scores between primiparas and multiparas

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/c4bc4a8c-12c2-4a6f-888d-5fc42ae45428image2.png

Figure 3

Distribution of participants - age wise

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/c4bc4a8c-12c2-4a6f-888d-5fc42ae45428image3.png

Discussion

The overall levels of 'birth satisfaction' were generally high. The first finding in the study was that, women who received Caesarean sections were found to have lesser satisfaction scores compared to the ones who underwent normal vaginal delivery. The literature by Jacoby A also supports that operative interference is often associated with reduced birth satisfaction.8 Out of the total 100 patients, 43% of the patients underwent Caesarean sections. It is evident that women undergoing operative procedures have more anxiety regarding the outcome and future complications that may occur after the procedure. Also, most of the women are not accustomed to the environment in the operation theatre which might lead to more stress and worry. It is therefore vital to counsel all women who are undergoing surgeries and mention the underlying risks and benefits of the same. With an increasing incidence of Caesarean sections in urban setups, it is necessary to make all attempts to reduce the stress and improve satisfaction scores.

The study also revealed that primiparas experienced a poorer score of birth satisfaction compared to multiparas. The probable explanation to this could be an increased tendency for primiparas to develop hypertensive disorders in pregnancy, which results in intrauterine growth retardation in our general population.9 Increased anxiety about complications is an important contributor to the reduced satisfaction scores in primiparous women. Experiencing labour for the first time can cause more worry and fear in women, which in turn reduces the satisfaction levels. Also, multiparous are more prepared due to prior experience with delivery.

Conclusion

Our study shows that the birth satisfaction is less among primiparas compared to multiparas and women who underwent caesarean section compared to normal delivery. The overall average score of the BSS-RI was 4.95. The BSS-RI has proved to be a useful tool in measuring the birth experiences of childbearing women.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.

References

1 

Department of Health. Changing childbirth: report of the expert maternity group (Cumberlege report). London: HMSO; 1993

2 

CH Martin V Fleming The birth satisfaction scaleInt J Health Care Qual Assurance20112421243510.1108/09526861111105086

3 

CR Martin CH Martin M Redshaw The Birth Satisfaction Scale-Revised Indicator (BSS-RI)BMC Pregnancy Childbirth201717127710.1186/s12884-017-1459-5

4 

M Johnson R Langdon L Yong H Stewart P Kelly Comprehensive measurement of maternal satisfaction: The modified Mason SurveyInt J Nurs Pract2002831273610.1046/j.1440-172x.2002.00353.x

5 

E K Main L Bloomfield G Hunt Sutter Health First Pregnancy and Delivery Clinical Initiative Committee Development of a large-scale obstetric quality-improvement program that focused on the nulliparous patient at termAm J Obstet Gynecol2004190174758

6 

PA Janssen CL Dennis B Reime Development and psychometric testing of the care in obstetrics: Measure for testing satisfaction (COMFORTS) scaleRes Nurs Health2006291516010.1002/nur.20112

7 

WE Peterson C Charles A DiCenso W Sword The Newcastle Satisfaction with Nursing Scales: a valid measure of maternal satisfaction with inpatient postpartum nursing careJ Adv Nurs20055266728110.1111/j.1365-2648.2005.03634.x

8 

A Jacoby Women’s preferences for and satisfaction with current procedures in childbirth: findings from a national studyMidwifery1987311724

9 

J Kaur K Kaur Obstetric complications: Primiparity versus multiparityEur J Exp Biol20122514628



jats-html.xsl

© This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License - Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0). which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.


Article type

Original Article


Article page

35-38


Authors Details

Madhumithaa N, N Hephzibah Kirubamani


Article History

Received : 11-11-2020

Accepted : 10-01-2021

Available online : 13-03-2021


Article Metrics


View Article As

 


Downlaod Files